Community
Sat, Sep 6 2008

A Complex Top Rail on a Fan-back Windsor

I'm again working on a new and bigger Windsor - one that is typical of those in Philadelphia in 1776. I found a design in Lester Margon's "More American Furniture Treasures", a fan-back with greatly raked legs.

While working up my SketchUp design, I was surprised in the design and positioning of the Top Rail. The surprise was how the Top Rail is horizontal as viewed in a front view. In my first attempt in making and placing the Top Rail in SketchUp, I saw the "surprise" with the ends of the Top Rail drifting upward away from horizontal. I couldn't figure out what was wrong and began to review pictures or other fan-back Windsors. I found some Top Rails did indeed rise up toward the ends. But I also saw examples with a flat horizontal Top Rail. So I began to develop a way of making this flat horizontal Top Rail which is shown below.

Here is an orthographic front and side view of the fan-back Windsor. This view is made from my incomplete SketchUp model with "parallel projection".  Notice the flatness of the Top Rail from ear-to-ear. If you simply bend a Top Rail and then rotate to line up with the recline of the back, the Top Rail will rise up at the ends when viewed in a front view. This fan-back is made without this rise toward the ends, so a simple bend will not work.

TopRail1 by you.


Step 1: I scanned the Margon drawings and imported into SketchUp. I then proceeded with the tracing-over of various components. Below are the trace-overs of the top and front views of the Top Rail (only one half the length).

TopRail2 by you.


Step 2: In this step I'm using both of these shapes from above in preparation of an Intersection used later in the process.

TopRail3 by you.


Step 3: If I arrange the components above such that I'm looking straight on in parallel projection, I can see how the "canted" rail piece in the back creates a rise above horizontal toward the end. Also, note how I've positioned the front face to be totally within the boundaries of the rear piece.

TopRail4 by you.


Step 4: In this step I am performing an Intersection of these two shapes.

TopRail5 by you.


Step 5: Here is the half-rail after the intersection and clean-up.

TopRail6 by you.


Step 6: I copy the half-rail, and combine with the other half rail to make the whole.

TopRail7 by you.


Step 7: Here is the "horizontal" Top Rail in place.

TopRail8 by you.


I have more design work to complete the spindles and shape the seat, but the hard part is done. However, I'm still not sure how I am going to bend and construct this Top Rail. I'm thinking to do a simple bend, then do the arc shaping after the bend.

Tim
http://killenwood.com

 

Comments (1)

  • 10/4/08 - NocomGenius! I would never have thought o fthat.

Learn the art and science of designing furniture in SketchUp with Fine Woodworking's design blog. Moderated by a devoted community of designer/woodworkers, we'll feature step-by-step tutorials for designing components, downloads of pre-built 3D models of furniture parts, and news and information about the evolving world of digital furniture design.

MEET THE
CONTRIBUTORS:
Dave Richards
Tim Killen


Blog Entries
Archive>

FROM THE
FINE WOODWORKING STORE


BUY NOW!
The H.O. Studley Tool Chest Poster
Admire the most elaborate tool chest known to woodworkers with this glossy, 18-in. by 26-in. poster.

Downloadthe wallpaper to your desktop

Visit the Fine Woodworking Store

Quick Links on FineWoodworking.com

Woodworker Profiles
Meet woodworkers around the world
Knots
Woodworking forum (free registration required)
Fine Woodworking magazine
A trusted resource for more than 30 years
Fine Woodworking eLetter
Woodworking information delivered to your inbox

Fine Woodworking Blogs

The Editor's Mailbox
Overheard and on the record
Design. Click. Build.
Expert tutorials for computer-aided furniture design
GlueTube
Woodworking videos by the people for the people
Inside Andy's Shop
Woodworker Andy Rae chats about doings in and around Asheville

Archived Blogs

The Smart Shop
Matthew Teague chronicles his shop in progress
Build a Tall Clock
Five students tackle this masterpiece
Built-In Media Cabinet
Furniture for your television
Book Notes
Book Notes is now a weekly feature in The Editor's Mailbox.

More Woodworking Blogs

The Wood Whisperer
A video podcast
Philsville
Commentary from a UK woodworker
Masashi's Woodworking Diary
Woodworking in Japan
Matt's Basement Workshop
An audio podcast
LumberJocks
A community of woodworkers
Kala Fine Furniture
Woodworking in Australia
Furnitology
A video podcast
David Charlesworth
Notes from the celebrated British craftsman
Cornish Workshop
Musings From The Workbench
Chair Notes
A resource for windsor chair makers and woodworkers
Refined Edge
The writings of a Canadian furniture designer who works mainly with hand tools.
Sandal Woods
An extensive site, featuring photos and video, from a woodworker in St. Joseph, Mo.
Woodworkers Resource
Website featuring experiences of woodworker, Craig Stevens, with video podcast.
Furnitude
Blog about design and handmade furniture
Working Wood
Boatbuilder Tom Fidgen blogs about woodworking tools, techniques, design, etc.
Dorset Custom Furniture
A look at works in progress from a customer furniture maker
Northwest Woodworking Studio
School founder and FWW contributing editor Gary Rogowski brings his unique sense of humor to woodworking. And life.
Northwest Woodworking Studio
A blog from a young Texas furniture maker.
The Wood Mechanic
From a professional cabinetmaker in Richmond, Va.

All Material Copyright The Taunton Press Inc.